Major joint replacement (hip/knee), with MCCMS-DRG 469Orthopedics

Median commercial negotiated rate by hospital, from each hospital's own disclosure file. The same procedure spans a 44.0× price range across 92 Colorado hospitals. Open in the explorer → — filter by insurer or region, map it, or compare hospitals side by side.

How to read “% of Medicare” Medicare’s payment is a hospital-specific benchmark built from CMS files — adjusted for local wages and case complexity, and roughly pegged to the cost of care. A commercial rate at 300% means a private plan pays about triple that benchmark for the same care at the same hospital. The gap is negotiation, not quality. Full methodology →
Median commercial negotiated rate Medicare benchmark
$21,907
$28,010
$29,064
$31,849
$35,697
$41,182
$44,929
$48,292
$49,529
$49,905
$53,077
$53,394
$53,415
$53,938
$54,588
$56,885
$58,360
$65,174
$65,914
$66,865
$68,074
$74,612
$90,047
$94,234
$110,616

The part you don’t feel

Erie County Medical Center $630,906vsAdirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake $14,333 what you pay what your plan pays
Deductible not metearly in the plan year
Erie County Medical Center
Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake
$616,572you feel all of it
Deductible met20% coinsurance
Erie County Medical Center
Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake
$123,314$493,258 invisible to you
Out-of-pocket max reacheda bad year, or a big surgery
Erie County Medical Center
Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake
$0the market goes blind

The gap is $616,572 in every row. The only thing that changes is how much of it reaches the person choosing. Nobody hid the price — the deductible structure hides the difference, and a difference nobody feels is a difference nobody shops. Illustration uses a 20% coinsurance plan with no separate facility or professional bill; your own plan governs.

Detail (click headers to sort, or “why” for cost vs price)

HospitalCommercial medianMedicare% of MedicareEst. cost*Plan rows
Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake$14,333$22,34664%$13,8712
Guthrie Cortland Regional Medical Center$21,327$22,34695%$61,4626
St James Hospital$21,907$22,34698%—2
Jones Memorial Hospital$22,006$22,34698%—3
Arnot Ogden Medical Center$23,025$22,346103%—5
Geneva General Hospital$27,593$22,346123%—3
F F Thompson Hospital$28,010$22,346125%—3
Upmc Chautauqua At Wca$28,057$22,346126%—3
Schuyler Hospital$29,064$22,346130%—2
Nicholas H Noyes Memorial Hospital$29,455$22,346132%—2
Montefiore Medical Center$29,521$22,346132%—6
Aurelia Osborn Fox Memorial Hospital$31,849$22,346143%$21,7741
Bassett Healthcare$31,849$22,346143%$41,7601
Highland Hospital$35,697$22,346160%—3
Brookdale Hospital Medical Center$36,992$22,346166%$63,91720
Our Lady Of Lourdes Memorial Hospital$37,340$22,346167%$44,5145
Samaritan Medical Center$37,657$22,346169%—5
Wyckoff Heights Medical Center$38,529$22,346172%—8
Nassau University Medical Center$39,657$22,346177%—9
Cayuga Medical Center At Ithaca$40,092$22,346179%—5
Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center$40,574$22,346182%—3
Saratoga Hospital$41,182$22,346184%—2
Bronxcare Hospital Center$42,750$22,346191%$24,60126
St John'S Episcopal Hospital At South Shore$44,407$22,346199%—10
Corning Hospital$44,929$22,346201%$26,1075
Ellis Hospital$48,292$22,346216%—1
South Brooklyn Health$49,529$22,346222%—17
St Barnabas Hospital$49,905$22,346223%—4
Flushing Hospital Medical Center$49,913$22,346223%—15
Strong Memorial Hospital$51,707$22,346231%—3
St Joseph'S Hospital Health Center$52,074$22,346233%—15
St John'S Riverside Hospital$52,298$22,346234%—6
Sisters Of Charity Hospital$52,323$22,346234%$34,25515
Mount St. Mary'S Hospital & Health Center$52,323$22,346234%$36,67813
Glens Falls Hospital$53,077$22,346238%—2
Kenmore Mercy Hospital$53,394$22,346239%$35,55314
Mercy Hospital Of Buffalo$53,394$22,346239%$38,66714
Crouse Hospital$53,415$22,346239%—6
Oswego Hospital$53,938$22,346241%—2
Wynn Hospital$54,588$22,346244%$23,5117
Jamaica Hospital Medical Center$54,903$22,346246%—16
Richmond University Medical Center$56,722$22,346254%—10
Jacobi Medical Center$56,885$22,346255%—17
Columbia Memorial Hospital$57,836$22,346259%—4
Harlem Hospital Center$58,360$22,346261%—16
Lincoln Medical & Mental Health Center$60,324$22,346270%—17
Elmhurst Hospital Center$60,324$22,346270%—17
Chsli St Joseph Hospital$61,432$22,346275%—35
Kings County Hospital Center$62,465$22,346280%—17
Nathan Littauer Hospital ● actual$63,530$22,346284%—3
St Joseph'S Medical Center$64,632$22,346289%—2
St Peter'S Hospital$65,174$22,346292%—20
Samaritan Hospital Of Troy, New York$65,174$22,346292%—20
Queens Hospital Center$65,914$22,346295%—17
The University Of Vermont Health Network - Champl$66,376$22,346297%—2
Bellevue Hospital Center$66,827$22,346299%—17
Mercy Medical Center$66,865$22,346299%—35
St Catherine Of Siena Hospital$67,126$22,346300%—35
Woodhull Medical & Mental Health Center$68,020$22,346304%—17
St Charles Hospital$68,074$22,346305%—35
Metropolitan Hospital Center$69,706$22,346312%—17
Brooklyn Hospital Center - Downtown Campus$71,434$22,346320%—9
Suny/Stony Brook University Hospital$72,694$22,346325%—1
Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center$74,052$22,346331%—35
Nyack Hospital$74,612$22,346334%—20
Long Island Community Hospital$78,536$22,346351%—161
University Hospital S U N Y Health Science Center$79,500$22,346356%—5
Healthalliance Hospital Marys Avenue Campus$87,007$22,346389%—13
Margaretville Memorial Hospital$87,007$22,346389%—11
Nyu Langone Hospitals$90,047$34,970257%—172
Bon Secours Community Hospital$90,837$22,346406%—14
St Francis Hospital - The Heart Center$91,589$24,516374%—35
Montefiore New Rochelle Hospital$93,481$22,346418%—22
Northwell Hospital Glen Cove$94,234$22,346422%—25
John T Mather Memorial Hospital Of Port Jefferson$94,234$22,346422%—24
Plainview Hospital$94,234$22,346422%—24
Peconic Bay Medical Center$94,657$22,346424%—24
Ns/Lij Hs Southside Hospital$95,080$22,346425%—24
Northern Westchester Hospital$95,080$22,346425%—25
Montefiore St Luke'S Cornwall$97,336$22,346436%—29
Good Samaritan Hospital Of Suffern$97,554$22,346437%—14
Albany Medical Center Hospital$103,255$22,346462%—7
Montefiore Mount Vernon Hospital$105,360$22,346471%—21
Ns/Lij Hs Huntington Hospital$105,704$22,346473%—24
Staten Island University Hospital$106,177$22,346475%—25
New York-Presbyterian Hospital$109,824$36,812298%—19
North Shore University Hospital$110,616$22,346495%—25
Lenox Hill Hospital$110,616$22,346495%—24
Long Island Jewish Medical Center$110,616$26,116424%—24
White Plains Hospital Center ● actual$135,515$22,346606%—18
Westchester Medical Center$145,326$22,346650%—16
Erie County Medical Center$630,906$22,3462823%—1

*Cost estimates use hospital-level cost-to-charge ratios from federal cost reports and are approximate; ~ marks categories (imaging, labs) where they are least precise. "Plan rows" is how many distinct plan rates the hospital published; medians over more rows are sturdier.
Something look wrong on this page? Tell us.
Thank you. A person reads every one of these.
Rexroad Analytics · Data: hospital machine-readable files (45 CFR 180, schema v3.0) retrieved September 28 – October 6, 2026; Medicare benchmarks from CMS claims data and fee schedules; cost estimates from FY2026 CMS cost-report ratios, labeled as estimates. Not medical, legal, or benefits advice. Full methodology → · The American Healthcare Conundrum →