Excision of breast lesionCPT 19120General surgery

Median commercial negotiated rate by hospital, from each hospital's own disclosure file. The same procedure spans a 4.4× price range across 95 Colorado hospitals. Open in the explorer → — filter by insurer or region, map it, or compare hospitals side by side.

How to read “% of Medicare” Medicare’s payment is a hospital-specific benchmark built from CMS files — adjusted for local wages and case complexity, and roughly pegged to the cost of care. A commercial rate at 300% means a private plan pays about triple that benchmark for the same care at the same hospital. The gap is negotiation, not quality. Full methodology →
Median commercial negotiated rate Medicare benchmark
$3,117
$3,127
$3,607
$3,720
$3,749
$3,950
$3,967
$4,050
$4,164
$4,303
$4,318
$4,318
$4,594
$4,596
$6,138
$6,181
$6,895
$7,905
$9,860
$13,586

The part you don’t feel

Nyu Langone Hospitals $13,586vsCrouse Hospital $3,117 what you pay what your plan pays
Deductible not metearly in the plan year
Nyu Langone Hospitals
Crouse Hospital
$10,469you feel all of it
Deductible met20% coinsurance
Nyu Langone Hospitals
Crouse Hospital
$2,094$8,375 invisible to you
Out-of-pocket max reacheda bad year, or a big surgery
Nyu Langone Hospitals
Crouse Hospital
$0the market goes blind

The gap is $10,469 in every row. The only thing that changes is how much of it reaches the person choosing. Nobody hid the price — the deductible structure hides the difference, and a difference nobody feels is a difference nobody shops. Illustration uses a 20% coinsurance plan with no separate facility or professional bill; your own plan governs.

Detail (click headers to sort, or “why” for cost vs price)

HospitalCommercial medianMedicare% of MedicareEst. cost*Plan rows
Nathan Littauer Hospital⚠ data flag$385$4,8888%$26524
Clifton Springs Hospital And Clinic⚠ data flag$457$4,8889%—1
Arnot Ogden Medical Center⚠ data flag$482$4,88810%—4
Bertrand Chaffee Hospital⚠ data flag$500$4,88810%$43118
United Memorial Medical Center⚠ data flag$579$4,88812%—3
F F Thompson Hospital⚠ data flag$610$4,88812%—14
St Anthony Community Hospital⚠ data flag$670$4,88814%$17912
O'Connor Hospital⚠ data flag$726$4,00018%—12
Cobleskill Regional Hospital⚠ data flag$778$4,00019%—16
Newark-Wayne Community Hospital⚠ data flag$802$4,88816%—1
Nicholas H Noyes Memorial Hospital⚠ data flag$818$4,88817%—18
Adirondack Medical Center - Saranac Lake⚠ data flag$845$4,88817%$4175
Little Falls Hospital⚠ data flag$882$4,00022%—13
St James Hospital⚠ data flag$997$4,88820%—16
Cuba Memorial Hospital⚠ data flag$1,037$4,00026%—3
Oneida Health Hospital⚠ data flag$1,425$4,88829%$42821
Nassau University Medical Center⚠ data flag$1,565$4,88832%—4
St Joseph'S Medical Center⚠ data flag$1,716$4,88835%—3
Montefiore Medical Center⚠ data flag$1,831$4,88837%$90994
Lewis County General Hospital⚠ data flag$2,161$4,00054%—8
Bronxcare Hospital Center⚠ data flag$2,250$4,88846%$4,23343
Westfield Memorial Hospital⚠ data flag$2,700$4,88855%$60724
Suny/Downstate University Hospital Of Brooklyn⚠ data flag$2,894$4,88859%$2,87918
Crouse Hospital$3,117$4,88864%—11
Wynn Hospital$3,127$4,88864%$39341
Garnet Health Medical Center Catskills$3,171$4,88865%—11
Auburn Community Hospital$3,317$4,88868%$14818
Wyckoff Heights Medical Center$3,389$4,88869%$3,24923
Brooks-Tlc Hospital System$3,426$4,88870%—6
Columbia Memorial Hospital$3,464$4,88871%$1,41020
Upmc Chautauqua At Wca$3,479$4,88871%—6
Garnet Health Medical Center$3,544$4,88873%—14
Nyack Hospital$3,607$4,88874%—39
Montefiore New Rochelle Hospital$3,607$4,88874%—48
Montefiore Mount Vernon Hospital$3,652$4,88875%—50
Glens Falls Hospital$3,720$4,88876%$1,80321
Saratoga Hospital$3,749$4,88877%$2,80719
Brooklyn Hospital Center - Downtown Campus$3,891$4,88880%$2,4777
Elmhurst Hospital Center$3,913$4,88880%$1,71363
Kings County Hospital Center$3,943$4,88881%$1,48263
Ny Eye And Ear Infirmary Of Mount Sinai$3,948$4,88881%—10
South Brooklyn Health$3,950$4,88881%$1,66362
Metropolitan Hospital Center$3,955$4,88881%$2,23663
Woodhull Medical & Mental Health Center$3,960$4,88881%$2,17063
Harlem Hospital Center$3,963$4,88881%$1,81862
Jacobi Medical Center$3,967$4,88881%$1,81863
Bellevue Hospital Center$3,967$4,88881%$1,66963
Lincoln Medical & Mental Health Center$3,970$4,88881%$1,96663
Erie County Medical Center$3,972$4,88881%$75028
Queens Hospital Center$3,973$4,88881%$1,89563
River Hospital Clinics$4,000$4,000100%—7
Ellis Hospital$4,050$4,88883%$1,26312
St Barnabas Hospital$4,164$4,88885%$3,34915
Albany Medical Center Hospital$4,212$4,88886%$1,06322
Kaleida Health$4,303$4,88888%—21
Northern Westchester Hospital$4,318$4,88888%—38
St Charles Hospital$4,318$4,88888%—89
Mercy Medical Center$4,318$4,88888%—90
Chsli St Joseph Hospital$4,318$4,88888%—78
St Catherine Of Siena Hospital$4,318$4,88888%—90
John T Mather Memorial Hospital Of Port Jefferson$4,322$4,88888%—38
Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center$4,341$4,88889%—78
Olean General Hospital$4,375$4,88890%—15
New York Community Hospital Of Brooklyn.$4,387$4,88890%—14
Montefiore St Luke'S Cornwall$4,410$4,88890%—36
Hudson Valley Hospital Center$4,488$4,88892%$1,34924
St Francis Hospital - The Heart Center$4,531$4,88893%—77
Jamaica Hospital Medical Center$4,555$4,88893%$1,44823
Flushing Hospital Medical Center$4,555$4,88893%$1,39823
Ns/Lij Hs Huntington Hospital$4,575$4,88894%—38
Jones Memorial Hospital$4,580$4,88894%—18
Rome Memorial Hospital$4,593$4,88894%$9,8468
Northwell Hospital Glen Cove$4,594$4,88894%—38
Plainview Hospital$4,594$4,88894%—38
Ns/Lij Hs Southside Hospital$4,596$4,88894%—38
North Shore University Hospital$4,596$4,88894%—38
Lenox Hill Hospital$4,596$4,88894%—38
Long Island Jewish Medical Center$4,596$4,88894%—38
Richmond University Medical Center$4,790$4,88898%—15
Niagara Falls Memorial Medical Center$4,864$4,888100%$7009
St John'S Riverside Hospital$4,864$4,888100%$3,35117
Brookdale Hospital Medical Center$4,888$4,888100%$3,58831
University Hospital S U N Y Health Science Center$5,029$4,888103%$1,84212
Staten Island University Hospital$5,130$4,888105%—38
Healthalliance Hospital Marys Avenue Campus$5,187$4,888106%—17
Margaretville Memorial Hospital$5,187$4,000130%—13
Maimonides Medical Center$5,246$4,888107%—16
Peconic Bay Medical Center$5,263$4,888108%—38
Carthage Area Hospital$5,400$4,000135%—3
Suny/Stony Brook University Hospital$5,490$4,888112%$1,84518
Chenango Memorial Hospital$5,865$4,888120%—7
Samaritan Medical Center$6,028$4,888123%$2,8608
Mount Sinai West$6,138$4,888126%—15
St Peter'S Hospital$6,181$4,888126%$1,344118
Samaritan Hospital Of Troy, New York$6,181$4,888126%—112
Long Island Community Hospital$6,200$4,888127%$961278
The University Of Vermont Health Network - Champl$6,280$4,888128%—10
New York-Presbyterian/Queens$6,468$4,888132%—18
White Plains Hospital Center$6,730$4,888138%—26
Mount Sinai South Nassau$6,867$4,888140%—10
Highland Hospital$6,895$4,888141%—7
New York-Presbyterian Hospital$7,207$4,888147%—19
Bon Secours Community Hospital$7,230$4,888148%—14
Good Samaritan Hospital Of Suffern$7,230$4,888148%—14
Westchester Medical Center$7,423$4,888152%—16
Northern Dutchess Hospital$7,585$4,888155%—7
Vassar Brothers Medical Center$7,839$4,888160%—5
Mount Sinai Hospital$7,905$4,888162%—15
Putnam Hospital Center$8,013$4,888164%—8
Strong Memorial Hospital$8,614$4,888176%—7
Geneva General Hospital$8,623$4,888176%—3
Delaware Valley Hospital$8,755$4,000219%—4
The University Of Vermont Health Network-Alice Hy$9,020$4,000225%—3
Oswego Hospital$9,860$4,888202%$2,9103
United Health Services Hospitals$10,191$4,888209%—8
St Joseph'S Hospital Health Center$10,671$4,888218%—73
Hospital For Special Surgery$12,245$4,888251%—89
Nyu Langone Hospitals$13,586$4,888278%$1,271270

*Cost estimates use hospital-level cost-to-charge ratios from federal cost reports and are approximate; ~ marks categories (imaging, labs) where they are least precise. "Plan rows" is how many distinct plan rates the hospital published; medians over more rows are sturdier.
Something look wrong on this page? Tell us.
Thank you. A person reads every one of these.
Rexroad Analytics · Data: hospital machine-readable files (45 CFR 180, schema v3.0) retrieved September 28 – October 6, 2026; Medicare benchmarks from CMS claims data and fee schedules; cost estimates from FY2026 CMS cost-report ratios, labeled as estimates. Not medical, legal, or benefits advice. Full methodology → · The American Healthcare Conundrum →